I will not complain complain about my size, but I do want to express my frustration with labels. Often times I feel like women think that something around a size 6 is ideal (highlight on the women think). Ideal for who? What height?
If you're of an average female height, I am probably a head taller then you. I'm supposed to be bigger then you, I'm supposed to weight more then you and for goodness sake my waist should also be wider. I'm talking significantly... According to the BMI chart, I'm supposed to be 15lbs heavier than a typical 5'5" women. In fact being 125lbs is slightly overweight for a 4'11" women and almost underweight for my 5'8" frame.
Same way, my waistline can be bigger then an average women's. Apparently the cutoff line for a healthy waste is your height in inches divided by 2. For me that will be 34 inches, for a 5'4" women that magic number will be 32 inches. Two inches around the waist makes a difference between a size 6 and a size 10. Crazy ha?
So when you say size 6, it will mean a whole world of a difference based on that person's height. Models are around a size 2-4 and they look like sticks that will break in half if you poke them- that's because they're tall. Women of my height are not meant to be size 0 or 2, it's unnatural for our frames. The reason why these tiny sizes were created is for short females under 5'.
It sometimes feel hard for me in this size obsessed world when women start saying bullshit about ideal sizes. I guess I'm lucky being slim, but I can see it being frustrating for other women my height. I'm not sure how I'd feel wearing something of a double digit size, however a size 10 or 12 certainly doesn't make someone my height fat at all.
Interpret this post however way you want, I certainly wasn't sure how it would evolve. I guess I just wanted to highlight that we need to stop characterizing people as skinny/ fat based on a size because we all have different frames and heights. I'm sure you guys being more health educated don't, however I feel like the general public does.
What's your take on dress sizes?
The underlined part is EVERYTHING I believe too. Dress size and what size I am has never bothered me because it varies from so many stores and you're right - our height/frame/body type makes it so hard to tell, so I don't really think it's an accurate indicator.
ReplyDeleteI could go on and on about this body image/size obsessed world and how damaging it is for women because the pressure is just ridiculous. grrr :(
And by the way, I always think less time in front of the TV is a positive thing! :D
My opinion is that sizes are sooooo arbitrary. Depending what part of my body I am fitting I may wear a few different sizes. Not to mention that every company makes sizes differently...and really we should all just be healthy and not sweat the numbers!
ReplyDeleteI'm glad that you guys understand this but I wish the whole "North American world" thought about it the same way. Even more so the younger generation...
ReplyDeleteAh!!! Dress sizes are such loads of BS. Especially for someone who shops exclusively in thrift stores - it's not uncommon for me to grab clothes ranging from size 0 to 6. One brand's 4 may fit, while another brand's 6 will fit. It's crazy.
ReplyDeleteLol, it's even funnier when you try on the exact same two pieces of clothing of the same size and they fit differently -.-
ReplyDeleteIt is so frustrating that so much emphasis is put on women's (and girl's...ugh!) dress sizes. I danced classical ballet for 12 years, and in that world it's horrendous. It went beyond dress size to costume size...if you didn't fit the costume, you didn't get to dance the role. Total BS. Now I just focus on fitness and how I feel. I also pay more attention to building muscle and losing fat, not weight. There's a HUGE difference. I want my daughter to grow up feeling beautiful and comfortable in her skin...no matter her dress size.
ReplyDeleteAre you serious 0.0 Wow... ballerina are already so skinny too :S It's kind of annoying for me because I've been doing a lot of running lately and things like squats/ lunges and all that jazz. So yea... my legs have gotten muscular (like I have no fat in that area) but my legs still got bigger because muscle still takes up space! It's great that you want your daughter to realize it!
ReplyDeleteOh my my my. I always take in at least 3 sizes when I try something on, usually I go just by how something looks, but it's brutal out there for sure. Here in the U.S. they do a lot of vanity sizing. They'll take a 10 at the Gap and size it to a 6 so you'll feel better about yourself. Lame. No wonder our sizes are all screwy. We should adopt the European measurements so there's no guessing.
ReplyDeleteAre you serious about the GAP pants!? That's very messed :S LMAO! So I completely just checked the Canadian size chart for GAP and it seems normal... Not sure if this is just a USA thing or do they purposely sew things smaller. WoW! It's actually really frustrating because I'm transitioning from shopping at teen stores to adult stores. I've had so much trouble finding where to start looking for my size :S
ReplyDeleteMy biggest pet peeve is when I go to buy clothes and everything is SO long. I'm short. I wear a smaller size. WHY do they make jeans in small sizes long enough to fit a person who's 6'2?!
ReplyDeleteHaha! As a teenager I was the exact opposite! For my pants to be long enough they would have to be big around the hips... My friends bought me belts for my birthday (I think that says it all).
ReplyDelete